Comments on: Delay seen for RIM’s new BlackBerry

By: Admore, London

Admore, London — Tue, 16 Sep 2008 15:09:04 +0000

I have been waiting for the Blackberry 9000 since June. My provider (TMobile-UK) seem to be clueless abt when it will be released here…does anyome have the inside scoop?

By: Boy Genius, New York NY

Boy Genius, New York NY — Wed, 25 Jun 2008 17:03:17 +0000

lol, we’re arguing over my traffic now? Here’s a figure: over 1.5M uniques a month.

By: Michael Emerson, New York, NY

Michael Emerson, New York, NY — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 00:21:28 +0000

@dr. martinelli:

Boy Genius has a following of “millions of blackberry users”??? Sorry, Doctor, but he doesn’t have nearly that many readers. Quantcast puts traffic for boygeniusreport.com at 26,623 US uniques, while Compete gives them 125k. That’s hardly “millions of blackberry users”.

Also, there is a huge difference between a “rumor blog” like Boy Genius and an esteemed print (and no online) publication like Fortune. BG can post whatever he want, when he wants to, with no responsibility to fact-check or be right. Fortune and other major publications, on the other hand, have a comprehensive system of fact checking, as they are accountable to actual stakeholders. Pubs like Fortune, et al., check facts, confirm sources, and make getting right a priority. Boy Genius posts whatever he hears and has no obligation to fact-check and confirm multiple sources. I would venture a guess that Fortune’s source is totally different than that of Boy Genius Report’s. As such, a confirmed source, Fortune has ZERO obligation to cite the other “rumor blog”.

Cheers,
MEE

By: Gary Rybold, Irvine, CA

Gary Rybold, Irvine, CA — Sat, 26 Apr 2008 10:45:12 +0000

Danny, a decision by AT&T to make changes to it’s normal business dealings to accomodate Apple probably isn’t the worst idea. As we know, millions of people Globally have said the reason that they have not bought an iPhone is because they are waiting for a 3G version. My prediction is that all of the people that have been waiting, will now buy one. Globally. And AT&T knows that. A 3G iPhone has a HUGE revenue advantage Globally over 3G Blackberry. (for the record, I like Blackberry and iPhone, and I hope that both of them success in the future)

By: dr. martinelli new york city NY

dr. martinelli new york city NY — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 23:44:13 +0000

this whole post is false and not only that it has been stolen and completely causing a whole blackberry community to reflect on this information. this was first and for most reported by http://WWW.BOYGENIUSREPORT.COM well well over a month ago and even prior to that. and you take information, false information and release it to people. the truth in the story that was stolen from boy genius, and now posted on here with false information. reading this is making me repulsed. you want the facts. read it at boygeniusreport.com and in no way am i affiliated with bg or his site other then being on it every single day. and i give him and his team credit for doing full research on things before they are posted. he has a following of millions of blackberry users. and i am one myself as well as knowing many people in the rim industry. who have read and commented as well as fowarded me this redundant article. do your research before posting false information……. legal department at rim has been sent the link to this article because you have forgot to use words like its rumored, speculation, possible, etc. you write in terms like you have concrete evidence.. went you have false wonderings. enjoy

By: Curtis Lemansky, NYC NY

Curtis Lemansky, NYC NY — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 22:57:38 +0000

The writer of this blog and/or CNN and Fortune need to go ahead and just update this blog and make sure they made a mistake. The BlackBerry Community is a tight-knit one and will be tearing this up until done so…trust me.

And to prove even more that Scott didn’t do his homework:

ScreenShot of 9000 (not 8900) “About” page:
http://www.engadgetmobile.com/photos/blackberry-9000-in-the-wild-1/723625/

ScreenShot of the 9000 (not the 8900 with the flat keys, chrome ring, etc) next to the 8800 and 8300:
http://www.engadgetmobile.com/photos/blackberry-9000-in-the-wild-1/723638/

By: MP, toronto ON

MP, toronto ON — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 20:37:06 +0000

this soty was stolen from

http://www.boygeniusreport.com/2008/04/25/cleaning-up-those-blackberry-rumors/

By: TheOutsider, Chicago IL

TheOutsider, Chicago IL — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 20:29:45 +0000

1. Mr. Moritz, you need to do a little more research on these claims. Posts like this make not only yourself look ignorant, but also Fortune and CNN. The 9000 series BlackBerry devices are not touchscreen. Don’t expect a touchscreen BlackBerry for atleast a year. The “silver metal edge, curved corners and flatter QWERTY keyboard” that you make reference to is the 9000 series BlackBerry, not the 8900 series BlackBerry. I would be happy to provide proof to you on this.

@ Wayne Schulz:
BTW, the gadget news website you refer to (BoyGeniusReport) has a well-known track record of having correct and accurate information. Anyone who viewed the photoshopped “touchscreen” BlackBerry and thought that it was legit needs to have an IQ performed in the near future. I am even surprised that the site actually had to post a story stating that it was a fake. Any person with common sense would have known that was a bogus post.

By: Wayne Schulz, Glastonbury, CT

Wayne Schulz, Glastonbury, CT — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 13:02:48 +0000

I think this marks the first signal of a market top for the dominance of the Blackberry.

The era of push email being anything amazing is long gone.

Blackberry is vulnerable in these 5 areas:

1. Lack of html email
2. Requirement of expensive BIS or BES add-on to do anything useful (yes I know people use BB without the plans but to do anything really useful with a BB you need a plan)
3. Insanely bad web browser
4. Push contacts, calendar, email becoming common on other platforms
5. The 3G iPhone will suck all the oxygen out of the developer space – as iPhones grow in popularity third party development for Blackberry will stall

BTW, the reputable gadget news website is the same one which circulated a photoshopped Blackberry image without disclosing it until about 20 sites picked up the image and ran it as fact. Reader beware.

By: Danny, Hollywood, CA

Danny, Hollywood, CA — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 07:48:00 +0000

Since when does AT&T care about call quality? Their over use of the AMR-HR codec sounds like crap and is used all over their 2/2.5G network.

Apple might be putting pressure on AT&T to make sure their new 3G iPhone gets all the attention at launch and true to form AT&T is putting them above all else; even if it means putting RIM in 2nd place.

Now would be a perfect time for T-Mobile to step up to the plate and work out a deal for an early release of this new BlackBerry for use with their new upcoming 3G network (if they ever turn on the damn thing).

By: Paul S Salt Lake City UT

Paul S Salt Lake City UT — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 02:25:48 +0000

Apple demanding a 3G launch to themselves seems plausible to me. Also Apple and RIM entering AT&T’s HSDPA network at the same time would cause legitimate concerns over network capability. I have no idea if the aforementioned speculation is accurate but it wouldn’t surprise me.

By: James Madison, Miami, FL

James Madison, Miami, FL — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 00:27:44 +0000

Gary, you’re right, much more opinion than actual fact.

By: Bb9000 new York city

Bb9000 new York city — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 00:18:25 +0000

this article is completely false. I work for rim. There is no 8900 series. As far as touch screen I can’t comment but in the up and comming (soon) 3g hsdpa blackberry 9000 will be released on att on scedual. You need to make corrections or state that this is rummors and unfounded to say the least. Please do more research before stating unfounded false assumptions. Thank you

By: Jibi, Atlanta, Georgia

Jibi, Atlanta, Georgia — Thu, 24 Apr 2008 22:23:19 +0000

Scott, there are a few items in your article that are wrong. The new device is not an 8900. It is in fact named the BlackBerry 9000. There is no BlackBerry 8900. A new device later on this year will likely be the BlackBerry 9100 or something else, but there’s been no definitive proof as to it being a touchscreen device.

I understand the need to provide some appealing aspects to your articles (I write about BlackBerry for a reputable gadget news website), however simple research will show the flaws in your article.

By: Griz S, Toronto

Griz S, Toronto — Thu, 24 Apr 2008 21:36:57 +0000

Good news for Apple

By: Gary Rybold, Irvine, CA

Gary Rybold, Irvine, CA — Thu, 24 Apr 2008 20:51:34 +0000

Although I respect the reporters opinions, I disagree that AT&T would try to delay RIM’s new phone, so that people would buy iPhone instead. AT&T is not Apple. AT&T makes money off of both RIM and iPhone. Verizon, because of it’s unconventional technology, won’t get the RIM until months later. For AT&T, launching a new RIM now means more subscribers over Verizon. When the iPhone comes out later, it will just be icing on the cake. Doesn’t makes sense to me.